Two Malibu Sandals, Two Different Looks
Freshly Picked offers two Malibu sandals that share a similar T-strap silhouette and Italian prong-free buckle, but their colors and some details set them apart. The Cherry Malibu brings a bold red leather finish, while the Platinum Malibu II offers a metallic silver sheen. This guide compares their color, fit, and features so you can choose the right pair for your little explorer.
Color and Finish at a Glance
- Cherry Malibu: Cherry Malibu features a leather T-strap upper, prong-free Italian buckles, soft leather insole, and cushioned rubber sole. The red leather is a classic, vibrant choice that pairs easily with neutral or bright outfits. The cherry color stands out and is ideal for parents who want a pop of color.

Cherry Malibu - Platinum Malibu II Sandal: Platinum Malibu II Sandal is crafted from genuine leather with a custom Italian prong-free buckle, genuine leather insole, and cushioned rubber outsole. The platinum metallic finish gives a modern, shiny look that can dress up casual summer outfits. It's a versatile neutral that works with many color palettes.

Platinum Malibu II Sandal
Key Differences: Cherry Malibu vs Platinum Malibu II
- Color: Cherry Malibu is a solid red leather. Platinum Malibu II has a metallic silver sheen.
- Fit Guidance: For the Platinum Malibu II, Freshly Picked recommends sizing up one size compared to FP baby shoes, and it runs true to size compared to regular shoes. The Cherry Malibu does not have specific fit guidance in its supplied information.
- Pricing: Cherry Malibu is listed at USD 29.70 (catalog comparison price USD 45.00). Platinum Malibu II is USD 27.90 (catalog comparison price USD 45.00). Both are on sale.
- Return Policy: Cherry Malibu is marked as final sale with no returns or exchanges. The Platinum Malibu II return policy is not specified in the supplied information.
Choosing the Right Color for Your Child
Both sandals share the same T-strap design, cushioned rubber sole, and ouch-free buckles. The main decision is color: cherry red for a bold, classic look, or platinum metallic for a modern, shiny finish. Consider your child's wardrobe and how often you want the sandal to stand out. If you need a specific fit recommendation, the Platinum Malibu II's sizing guidance may help you decide.


